^{This page is part of © FOTW Flags Of The World website}

Washington's Cruisers Flag (U.S.)

Historical

image by Rick Wyatt, 1 November 2002

Washington's Cruisers
Massachusetts Navy flag
An Appeal To Heaven flag
2024 Controversy

See also:

Editor's note: There are numerous varying references to the flags used by "Massachusetts Navy, Floating Batteries, Washington's Cruisers..."

Washington's Cruisers

source: Standards and Colors of the American Revolution[ric82]

In September 1775, the Americans launched two strong floating batteries on the Charles River, Massachusetts, and in the following month they opened fire on the enemy in Boston. In October, Washington also commissioned two schooners, the Lynch and the Franklin, to cruise the Bay. When speaking of these schooners, Col. Joseph Reed, Washington's secretary, in a letter from Cambridge, Mass. to Colonels Glover and Moyland, dated October 20, 1775, said
"Please fix upon some particular color for a flag, and a signal by which our vessels may know one another. What do you think of a flag with a white ground and a tree in the middle, the motto 'AN APPEAL TO HEAVEN' - this is the flag of our floating batteries."
By February 1, 1776 a total of six such "armed Vessels" of the "United Colonies of North America" had been commissioned by Washington... In April 1776, the Massachusetts council passed a series of resolutions for the regulation of the sea service, among which was the following: -
"Resolved, that the uniform of the officers be green and white, and that the colors be a white flag, with a green pine tree, and the inscription, 'An Appeal to Heaven'."

There also were flags with "We Appeal to Heaven" and "Appeal To Heaven".

Rick Wyatt, 1 November 2002

I believe the six cruisers were the Lynch, Franklin, Lee, Warren, Washington and Harrison. Other ships appear to have included in late 1776: the Hannah, Hancock, General Schuyler, General Mifflin, Lady Washington, Spitfire, and Montgomery.
Phil Nelson, 12 November 2004

The Lynch and the Franklin were schooners. Richardson's "Standards and Colors of the American Revolution" also mentions two strong floating batteries on the Charles River in Massachusetts. By Feb 1, 1776 a total of six such "Armed Vessels" of the "United Colonies of North America" had been commissioned by Washington.
Rick Wyatt, 13 November 2004

Massachusetts Navy Flag

image by Randy Young, 6 February 2001

Source: "Flags to Color from the American Revolution."

On page 2 is the "Massachusetts Navy Flag." The colors are described as "White field, green leaves and grass, brown trunk, black letters."
"In Sept. 1775, two floating batteries were launched on the Charles River and were soon firing on the enemy in Boston. These heavily armed scows flew this flag, as did the floating batteries of Pennsylvania on the Delaware River, and Washington's six schooners, commissioned early in 1776. The flag was officially adopted by the Massachusetts Navy in April 1776."

Randy Young, 6 February 2001

An Appeal To Heaven

image by Randy Young, 29 January 2001

Source: "Flags to Color from the American Revolution."

On page 1 is the "Appeal To Heaven Flag." The description of the flag is very simple: "White field" and black letters. The flag has the inscription "AN APPEAL TO HEAVEN" in capital letters interspersed with the inscription "une appellation au ciel" in lower case letters. Considering the English and French inscriptions, the flag was probably used following the Franco-American alliance in the latter part of the war.

Randy Young, 29 January 2001

2024 Controversy

First, "background" info from Wikipedia at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samuel_Alito

"On May 16, 2024, The New York Times published an article revealing that in [early] January 2021, an a_U.S._flag_upside_down was flown at the [U.S. Supreme Court Associate Justice Samuel] Alito household in Alexandria, Virginia. Multiple legal ethics experts considered this a clear violation of ethics rules because flying the flag upside down was a symbol of the Stop_the_Steal movement at that time. On May 22, 2024, another New York Times article reported that a Pine_Tree_Flag ["An Appeal To Heaven"], which has been associated with January 6 [2021] rioters [in Washington, DC], was flown outside Alito's [Long Beach Island/Jersey Beach property at his] New Jersey residence during the summer of 2023. Since 2010, it has been argued that Christian_nationalism activists in the U.S. have appropriated the flag as a religious and political symbol."

New news article source: https://www.thedailybeast.com/san-francisco-civic-center-removes-flag

"San Francisco Center Removes Flag After Justice Samuel Alito Drama"
FLAG DOWN
https://www.thedailybeast.com/author/owen-lavine,
https://www.thedailybeast.com/author/owen-lavine
Published May 29, 2024 3:50PM EDT

"After a week of controversy surrounding [U.S. Supreme Court] Samuel-Alito 'Appeal to Heaven' flag, the same flag has been pulled down from the San Francisco Civic Center. The flag, which was popularized by Jan. 6 Capitol insurrectionists, who flew it along with other popular right-wing iconography and flags, has flown among the 18 flags outside the civic center for decades, according to the https://www.sfchronicle.com. The city's park service decided to remove the flag on Saturday. The park service said in a statement that the flag has been adopted by a group "that doesn't represent the city's values." The city has since replaced the flag with an American flag. The Chronicle noted that this isn't the first time San Francisco has had to remove a controversial flag. After the Confederate Flag [1861-1865 U.S. Civil War] was continually ripped down in protest in 1984, the city's then Mayor Dianne Feinstein agreed not to have the flag replaced."

William Garrison, 30 May 2024